Best Colby Cheese

324 reviews scanned and analysysed
Jennifer Williams
Jennifer Williams Writer
Last Updated: Oct 22, 2024 Share On:

You may wonder, what is the best colby cheese ?

After several hours of work by our experts, we have found 249 relevant products with prices ranging from $16.66 to $63.27.

Keep reading, and we will give you clear and unbiased advice.

A Quick Look: Our Top Picks

Top 1
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Cheese Longhorn 48Oz Half Loaf
9.9We rank the products based on a number of factors such as features, price, customer reviews and so on.

Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Cheese Longhorn 48Oz Half Loaf

Read More Check Price
Top 1 Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Cheese Longhorn 48Oz Half Loaf

Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Cheese Longhorn 48Oz Half Loaf

Read More Check Price
Top 2
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese
9.8We rank the products based on a number of factors such as features, price, customer reviews and so on.

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese

Read More Check Price
Top 2 Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese

Read More Check Price
Top 3
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block
9.7We rank the products based on a number of factors such as features, price, customer reviews and so on.

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block

Read More Check Price
Top 3 Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block

Read More Check Price

*Note The result is based on our independent research, and we are reader-supported and do not promote any brand or retailer. As a member of Amazon Marketing Affiliates, we may receive a commission from qualified purchases.

Top 20 Colby Cheese Reviews 2024 In Detail

1 Editor's Choice

Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Cheese Longhorn 48Oz Half Loaf

WISCONSIN CHEESE MARTBrand 2.5 lbWeight
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Cheese Longhorn 48Oz Half Loaf cover
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Cheese Longhorn 48Oz Half Loaf thumb #1
9.9We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Cheese Delicatessen ( 4.36 / 5 )
Features
  • A Wisconsin original cheese! The first Colby was made in 1874 in Colby, Wisconsinch
  • Longhorn is a style of American Colby cheese defined by its round, long, orange cylindrical shape.
2 Editor's Choice

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese

HAPPY BELLYBrand 8.75H*5.25L*1.0W inchesDimension 0.5 lbWeight
Ranked #20 in Best Monterey Jack Cheese Of 2024
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese cover
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese thumb #1Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese thumb #2Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese thumb #3Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese thumb #4Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese thumb #5
9.8We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • One 8-ounce resealable pack of 10 Colby Jack cheese slices
  • Good source of calcium. See nutrition panel for fat and saturated fat content
  • Contains milk
  • An Amazon brand
3 Editor's Choice

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block

HAPPY BELLYBrand 2.5H*6.75L*1.0W inchesDimension 0.5 lbWeight
Ranked #14 in Best Monterey Jack Cheese Of 2024
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block cover
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block thumb #1Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block thumb #2Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block thumb #3Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block thumb #4Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block thumb #5
9.7We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • One 8-ounce Colby Jack cheese block
  • Good source of calcium. See nutrition panel for fat and saturated fat content
  • Contains milk
  • An Amazon brand
4

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Shredded Colby Jack Cheese

HAPPY BELLYBrand 6.0H*8.5L*1.5W inchesDimension 0.5 lbWeight
Ranked #9 in Best Monterey Jack Cheese Of 2024
Ranked #18 in Best Cheeses Of 2024
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Shredded Colby Jack Cheese cover
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Shredded Colby Jack Cheese thumb #1Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Shredded Colby Jack Cheese thumb #2Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Shredded Colby Jack Cheese thumb #3
9.6We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • One 8-ounce resealable bag of shredded Colby Jack cheese
  • Good source of calcium. See nutrition panel for fat and saturated fat content.
  • Contains milk
  • An Amazon brand
5

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese

HAPPY BELLYBrand 1.75H*5.38L*1.5W inchesDimension 0.62 lbWeight
Ranked #10 in Best Packaged String & Snack Cheeses Of 2024
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese cover
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese thumb #1Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese thumb #2Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese thumb #3Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese thumb #4
9.5We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • One 10-ounce pack of 12 individually wrapped Colby Jack snack sticks
  • Good source of calcium. See nutrition panel for fat and saturated fat content
  • Contains milk
  • An Amazon brand
6

Kraft 00021000001903 Colby Cheese Block, 8 Oz Wrapper

KRAFTBrand 00021000001903Model 1.56H*1.56L*5.64W inchesDimension 0.4 lbWeight
Kraft 00021000001903 Colby Cheese Block, 8 Oz Wrapper cover
Kraft 00021000001903 Colby Cheese Block, 8 Oz Wrapper thumb #1Kraft 00021000001903 Colby Cheese Block, 8 Oz Wrapper thumb #2Kraft 00021000001903 Colby Cheese Block, 8 Oz Wrapper thumb #3Kraft 00021000001903 Colby Cheese Block, 8 Oz Wrapper thumb #4Kraft 00021000001903 Colby Cheese Block, 8 Oz Wrapper thumb #5
9.4We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • Perfect for your favorite recipes
  • 110 calories, 7 grams of protein per serving
  • Without the added hormone rbST*
  • Always made with fresh milk from U.S. dairy farms
  • Brought to you by Kraft, cheese making since 1914
7

365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482525408 Colby Jack Sliced Organic

365 BY WHOLE FOODS MARKETBrand 0099482525408Model 0.38 lbWeight
365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482525408 Colby Jack Sliced Organic cover
365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482525408 Colby Jack Sliced Organic thumb #1
9.3We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • Exclusively selected and passionately sourced from farmers and producers around the world
  • No hydrogenated fats, high-fructose corn syrup or added MSG
8

365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482412432 Colby Jack Bar, 8 Ounce

365 BY WHOLE FOODS MARKETBrand 0099482412432Model 0.88H*5.5L*2.75W inchesDimension 0.5 lbWeight
Ranked #15 in Best Monterey Jack Cheese Of 2024
365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482412432 Colby Jack Bar, 8 Ounce cover
365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482412432 Colby Jack Bar, 8 Ounce thumb #1365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482412432 Colby Jack Bar, 8 Ounce thumb #2365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482412432 Colby Jack Bar, 8 Ounce thumb #3365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482412432 Colby Jack Bar, 8 Ounce thumb #4365 By Whole Foods Market 0099482412432 Colby Jack Bar, 8 Ounce thumb #5
9.2We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • Produced without added hormones
  • Delicious natural cheese
  • Smooth, creamy flavor
9

Shullsburg Creamery Colby Cheese - 1 Pound

SHULLSBURG CREAMERYBrand 1.0 lbWeight
Shullsburg Creamery Colby Cheese - 1 Pound cover
9.1We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Excellent Price: $$$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Shullsburg Cheese Store ( 4.64 / 5 )
More On Amazon..
10

Shullsburg Creamery Colby Cheese - 6 Pound Mini Deli Horn

SHULLSBURG CREAMERYBrand 6.0 lbWeight
Shullsburg Creamery Colby Cheese - 6 Pound Mini Deli Horn cover
9.0We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Shullsburg Cheese Store ( 4.64 / 5 )
More On Amazon..
11

Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Slices Cracker Cuts

HAPPY BELLYBrand 2.12H*8.5L*3.62W inchesDimension 0.62 lbWeight
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Slices Cracker Cuts cover
Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Slices Cracker Cuts thumb #1Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Slices Cracker Cuts thumb #2Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Slices Cracker Cuts thumb #3Happy Belly Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Slices Cracker Cuts thumb #4
9.0We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • One 10-ounce resealable container of 30 slices of Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese cuts
  • Proportioned for topping a cracker
  • Good source of calcium. See nutrition panel for fat and saturated fat content
  • Contains milk
  • An Amazon brand
12

Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices

SARGENTOBrand 9.0H*0.75L*5.75W inchesDimension 0.47 lbWeight
Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices cover
Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices thumb #1Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices thumb #2Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices thumb #3Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices thumb #4Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices thumb #5Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices thumb #6Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices thumb #7Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices thumb #8
9.0We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • Natural cheese
  • 45 calories per slice
  • 20 Slices
  • Easy Close zipper
13

Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks

SARGENTOBrand 2.55H*7.75L*2.55W inchesDimension 0.56 lbWeight
Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks cover
Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks thumb #1Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks thumb #2Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks thumb #3Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks thumb #4Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks thumb #5Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks thumb #6Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks thumb #7Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Snack Sticks thumb #8
8.8We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • With 5 Grams of Protein per serving, Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Sticks keeps you satisfied through snack time and beyond.
  • Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Sticks are a natural source of Calcium, each individual stick contains 15% Calcium and 80 Calories. These Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.
  • When you need a quick and delicious snack to tide you over, choose Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Sticks to help fuel you through the day.
  • This order includes one 9-ounce package of Colby-Jack Natural Cheese sticks that contains 12 individual sticks.
14

Kraft Foods 284-11-0179 Kraft Cheese Fine Shredded Colby And Monterey Jack

KRAFT FOODSBrand 284-11-0179Model 8.75H*1.0L*6.5W inchesDimension 0.45 lbWeight
Ranked #13 in Best Monterey Jack Cheese Of 2024
Kraft Foods 284-11-0179 Kraft Cheese Fine Shredded Colby And Monterey Jack cover
Kraft Foods 284-11-0179 Kraft Cheese Fine Shredded Colby And Monterey Jack thumb #1Kraft Foods 284-11-0179 Kraft Cheese Fine Shredded Colby And Monterey Jack thumb #2Kraft Foods 284-11-0179 Kraft Cheese Fine Shredded Colby And Monterey Jack thumb #3Kraft Foods 284-11-0179 Kraft Cheese Fine Shredded Colby And Monterey Jack thumb #4Kraft Foods 284-11-0179 Kraft Cheese Fine Shredded Colby And Monterey Jack thumb #5Kraft Foods 284-11-0179 Kraft Cheese Fine Shredded Colby And Monterey Jack thumb #6
8.7We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • No rbGH/No rbST
  • Hormone Free/No Hormones/No Added Hormones/No Synthetic Hormones
15

Kraft 00021000002917 Natural Colby Jack Cheese

KRAFTBrand 00021000002917Model 8.0 lbWeight
Kraft 00021000002917 Natural Colby Jack Cheese cover
Kraft 00021000002917 Natural Colby Jack Cheese thumb #1Kraft 00021000002917 Natural Colby Jack Cheese thumb #2Kraft 00021000002917 Natural Colby Jack Cheese thumb #3Kraft 00021000002917 Natural Colby Jack Cheese thumb #4Kraft 00021000002917 Natural Colby Jack Cheese thumb #5Kraft 00021000002917 Natural Colby Jack Cheese thumb #6
8.7We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
More On Amazon..
16

New Bridge Colby Jack, 7 Oz, 12 Pack

NEW BRIDGEBrand 0.44 lbWeight
New Bridge Colby Jack, 7 Oz, 12 Pack cover
New Bridge Colby Jack, 7 Oz, 12 Pack thumb #1New Bridge Colby Jack, 7 Oz, 12 Pack thumb #2New Bridge Colby Jack, 7 Oz, 12 Pack thumb #3
8.7We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Spring Street Specialty Foods ( 4.72 / 5 )
Features
  • GMO-Free
  • Gluten-Free
  • Vegetarian
17

Celebrity Wisconsin Cheeseman Longhorn Colby 1-Lb.

CELEBRITYBrand 1.0 lbWeight
Celebrity Wisconsin Cheeseman Longhorn Colby 1-Lb. cover
8.6We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » Cheese Delicatessen ( 4.36 / 5 )
More On Amazon..
18

Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Jack Cheese 48Oz Half Loaf

WISCONSIN CHEESE MARTBrand 3.0 lbWeight
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Jack Cheese 48Oz Half Loaf cover
8.6We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Visit Store » WisconsinCheeseMart ( 4.8 / 5 )
Features
  • Diamond Marble (Colby Jack) is a classic American combination of Colby and Monterey Jack cheese. The cheeses are blended together before pressing, giving it a unique marbled appearance.
  • Semi-soft cheese, mild and smooth taste.
  • Great for melting! Try in macaroni and cheese, grilled cheese sandwiches, or cubed for a fun snack.
19

Kraft 00021000053728 Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese

KRAFTBrand 00021000053728Model 1.0 lbWeight
Kraft 00021000053728 Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese cover
Kraft 00021000053728 Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese thumb #1Kraft 00021000053728 Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese thumb #2Kraft 00021000053728 Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese thumb #3Kraft 00021000053728 Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese thumb #4Kraft 00021000053728 Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese thumb #5Kraft 00021000053728 Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese thumb #6
8.6We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • Kraft Finely Shredded Natural Colby Jack Shredded Cheese (16 oz Pouch)
  • Every batch of Kraft Cheese starts with fresh milk for creamy flavor
  • Say yes to the rich cheese taste you and your family will love
20

Kraft 284-11-0067 Big Slice Natural Colby Jack Cheese Slices

KRAFTBrand 284-11-0067Model 8.0 lbWeight
Kraft 284-11-0067 Big Slice Natural Colby Jack Cheese Slices cover
Kraft 284-11-0067 Big Slice Natural Colby Jack Cheese Slices thumb #1Kraft 284-11-0067 Big Slice Natural Colby Jack Cheese Slices thumb #2Kraft 284-11-0067 Big Slice Natural Colby Jack Cheese Slices thumb #3Kraft 284-11-0067 Big Slice Natural Colby Jack Cheese Slices thumb #4Kraft 284-11-0067 Big Slice Natural Colby Jack Cheese Slices thumb #5Kraft 284-11-0067 Big Slice Natural Colby Jack Cheese Slices thumb #6
8.6We rank the products based on several factors, like features, price, customer reviews, and so on.
Rating: Very Good Price: $$
Check On Amazon Search On eBay
Features
  • One 8 oz. package of Kraft Big Slice Colby Jack Cheese Slices
  • Kraft Big Slice Colby Jack Cheese Slices backed by years of cheese-making experience
  • Every batch of Kraft Cheese starts with fresh milk for creamy flavor
  • Say yes to the rich cheese taste you and your family will love
  • Perfect as cheese for sandwiches, burgers, or wraps

Best Colby Cheese Of 2024 Rating

Top Reviewed Colby Cheese

Popular Related

FAQ & Notes

Jennifer Williams Written By Jennifer Williams

During our research, we found more than 249 related products, with prices ranging from $16.66 to $63.27, and most customers would pay around $12 for this type of product.

What are the top brands of Colby Cheese?

There are 9 brands available for Colby Cheese, such as 365 By Whole Foods Market, Kraft Foods, Kraft, New Bridge, Happy Belly, Wisconsin Cheese Mart, Sargento, Celebrity, Shullsburg Creamery.

What are the available sellers for Colby Cheese?

There are 4 sellers available for Colby Cheese, including Shullsburg Cheese Store ( 4.64 / 5 ), WisconsinCheeseMart ( 4.8 / 5 ), Spring Street Specialty Foods ( 4.72 / 5 ), Cheese Delicatessen ( 4.36 / 5 ).

Price comparison of the top 10 Colby Cheese

*Note: Prices based on historical data.

Price comparison of the top 10 Colby Cheese highly recommended

*Note: Prices based on historical data.

The Verdict

After thorough consideration, we have selected the product Wisconsin Cheese Mart Colby Cheese as your preferred option.

As an alternative, we have also compiled a list based on user reviews, and the product Shullsburg Creamery Colby Cheese - is also worthy of your purchase.